First Class Bagels Deer Park
If you're searching for the ultimate bagel experience in Deer Park, look no further than First Class Bagels. Nestled at 1976 Deer Park Ave, this charming bagel shop is a delightful haven for both locals and visitors who appreciate quality and warm service. With a phone number at +1 631-586-9532, it's easy to reach out or plan your visit.
First Class Bagels takes pride in offering an impressive variety of freshly made bagels that will have you coming back for more. The ambiance here is inviting, exuding a sense of community and warmth that makes you feel like part of the family. As Christine T. beautifully notes, "You honestly feel like family going into First Class." It’s the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name, and first-time visitors are welcomed with open arms.
While the bagels are undoubtedly the star of the show—soft, chewy, and made fresh daily—you’ll also find an array of delectable options to satisfy your breakfast, lunch, or snack cravings. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic bacon, egg, and cheese or one of their numerous specialty sandwiches, each bite is a testament to quality and flavor. As Renee Cutaia mentions, the "selection of bagels" is quite impressive, and many customers appreciate the recent addition of mini bagels—perfect for gatherings and brunches.
If you have a flair for experimentation, you'll delight in their extensive selection of cream cheeses, providing a perfect complement to any bagel choice. Moreover, the staff here are not just friendly—they are genuinely attentive, ensuring that your experience is as delightful as the food itself. According to Warda Ahmed, the manager and staff are always "super helpful and kind," adding to the overall positive vibe of the establishment.
While some customers have noted slight variations in their orders, such as a lighter touch on fillings like tuna salad, the overall consensus is that First Class Bagels does bagels exceptionally well. The fresh, flavorful bagels combined with the clean, spacious setting and welcoming staff makes it a must-visit spot for anyone in the area.
So, whether you’re a long-time bagel lover or just stopping by, make First Class Bagels your go-to destination. As Bethany Rutherford puts it succinctly, "Loved it! Very friendly staff and tasty bagels." Don’t hesitate to stop by for an unforgettable bagel experience—you won’t regret it!
497 Reviews
21 Sep 2025
14 Sep 2025
09 Sep 2025
23 Aug 2025
14 Aug 2025
27 Jul 2025

Amma’s Kitchen

El Potro Mexican Restaurant

Two Cities Pizza Co.

Parking at Citizen Eatery
Join the First Class Bagels Deer Park Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.